Big Boxes, Mom-and-Pops, and the Tariff Impact on Retail

Holiday 2025 retail window display showing how the tariff impact on retail influences shopping centers

Big Boxes, Mom-and-Pops, and the Tariff Impact on Retail

What Holiday 2025 Holds for Shopping Centers

As I’ve been chasing down deals for my own home projects, window coverings, office enclosures, new hardwood floors, I noticed every invoice had a line for tariffs. I’m glad I ordered before they hit, but it got me thinking: how will this tariff impact on retail play out for retail this holiday season?

2025 feels like The Nightmare Before Christmas. Tariffs are climbing, inflation keeps biting, supply chains are shaky, and shopping centers are caught in the middle. Some favorites, like Joann, and the Big Lots near me, are already gone. The question is, who’s next?

Local shop sign representing small businesses affected by the tariff impact on retail

The Backdrop

  • Tariffs scare shoppers. One mention of the “T word” and retailers tell me sales drop instantly. The unpredictability makes it impossible to plan.
  • Supply chains are still messy. Delays, reroutes, and higher costs mean stores are padding inventory just in case.
  • Too much of the wrong stuff. Some of my retailers I work closely with stocked up early and now can’t move it. A shoe retailer told me he’s stuck with Pumas his customers no longer want. They are too expensive, and they are looking for a better value.
  • Shoppers are cautious. Value matters more than brand. They’re mixing online, off-price, and discount channels.
  • Retail space is softening. More stores are closing than opening. Vacancy is climbing, and most new tenants are not soft goods. With Macy’s and Kohl’s wobbling, I pray Amazon doesn’t end up our only fashion option.

Big Boxes

Why they may hold up:
They have scale, global sourcing, and balance sheets to ride out storms. They can shift suppliers, hedge costs, and lean on private labels.

Where they will struggle:
Margins are already thinner from tariffs. Extra inventory is forcing discounts. Operating costs for big stores remain heavy. Even so, they will likely come out battered but standing.

Mom-and-Pops

These are the ones I worry about most. Small shops do not have the buying power or wiggle room to absorb tariffs. They rely on fewer suppliers and cannot pivot quickly. Yet they are the soul of our shopping centers. Without them, retail becomes bland and predictable. I plan to purchase as many things as I can during my holiday shopping to help the small retailers.

Independent store owner standing in shop, illustrating the human side of the tariff impact on retail

Bottom Line

Big boxes will survive holiday 2025. Mom-and-pops will fight uphill. They are the ones that make our shopping centers vibrant and personal. The tariff impact on retail may bruise margins, but scale will keep them standing. Supporting small businesses might be the most important holiday shopping decision we make this year.

At CMA, we help brands adapt to shifting retail trends, from the tariff effect to changing shopper behavior. Let’s talk about how to keep your business thriving through every season.


AUTHOR

CMA Office Kim 4.3

Kim Kelley, Marketing Guru

Kim Kelley is the Principal at Creative Marketing Arts. With over 30 years in the Shopping Center industry, Kim offers creative ideas blended perfectly for REIT Advertising and Marketing. With an eye for perfection and creative flair, Kim offers all clients Out of the Box solutions.